Brendan Smialowski—AFP
Families demand the killings be treated as a hate crime and not a ‘parking dispute.’
The families of three Muslim students shot dead by a white neighbor in the U.S. said an emotional farewell to their loved ones on Thursday, reiterating calls for the killings to be treated as a hate crime.
More than 5,000 people gathered for the funeral of Deah Shaddy Barakat, 23, his new wife Yusor Mohammed Abu-Salha, 21, and her 19-year-old sister Razan Mohammed Abu-Salha, who authorities say were killed by a neighbor in the North Carolina university town of Chapel Hill. The alleged shooter, Craig Stephen Hicks, 46, was believed to be strongly opposed to religion, as his Facebook page showed dozens of anti-religious posts, including proclamations denouncing Christianity, Mormonism and Islam.
Police said they were investigating Tuesday’s fatal shootings as a parking dispute, but victims’ families repeated their belief the attack was religiously motivated. The Federal Bureau of Investigation said it had launched a parallel probe into the killings. Federal prosecutors often look into suspected hate-crime cases—a conviction for “hate crime” results in a tougher sentence.
“We are definitely certain that our daughters were targeted for their religion,” said the father of the sisters, Mohammed Abu-Salha. “This is not a parking dispute, these children were executed with shots in the back of the heads,” he said, surrounded by tearful family members as they prepared for the final funeral prayer. “This has hate crime written all over it and I’m not going to sit down for it,” he said later before three caskets.
He said his daughter Yusor had complained that Hicks had harassed her, and appeared at her door to complain about a parking space with a gun holstered at his waist. Neighbors recalled Hicks as troublesome, frequently squabbling with nearby residents over parking and seen with his gun in public, according to local media reports.
The killings rattled the Chapel Hill community, fueling fears among some Muslims in the tight-knit university town, but officials say it did not appear to be part of a broader anti-Muslim campaign. “To be honest, it makes me more scared because I have two babies so I don’t even want to imagine,” said Sarah Alhorani, a former student at University of North Carolina, where Barakat was a second year dentistry student. “I was scared to walk out my door, but I did and I kept going and I kept my scarf on and you keep moving on,” said Alhorani, a friend of all three victims.
Some Muslim leaders said the shooting was a reflection of wider anti-Muslim hostility, and warned it could sow fear among Muslim-Americans. “People are very concerned about what happened. They feel that this is a premeditated hate crime,” said Nihad Awad, director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations.
But there were calls for calm and leaders urged restraint.
“It’s time to mourn but it’s also time to call for harmony and peace,” said the head of the Islamic Association in neighboring Raleigh, Mohamed Elgamal.
There are some 65,000 Muslims in North Carolina, which has a population of 9.9 million, and the majority live in the Chapel Hill area. The killings sparked outrage among Muslims worldwide, with the Twitter hashtags #ChapelHillShooting and #MuslimLivesMatter trending globally.
Mohammed Abu-Salha rejected skewed perceptions of Muslims, and said the slain youngsters and the support they garnered were exemplars of the faith. “This is Islam, it’s not what you hear in the media, it’s not American Sniper,” he said, referring to a film about a shooter killing Islamists in the Iraq war.
Relatives and friends honored the trio at a traditional Muslim service. Tearful crowds followed the funeral hearse to an outdoor service, where thousands gathered to kneel and pray.
“If you loved them, know that we are proud of them that they are Muslim,” said Noumann Siddiqui, Islamic Council member. “All of us, Muslims, Christians and Jews alike put love in our hearts. All lives matter.”
The victims’ parents wept as their children were buried, the sisters together in one grave next to Deah, while prayers echoed from the crowd. Deah and Yusor were married on Dec. 27, and the new bride was set to attend UNC dentistry school in August.