Pakistan can do better. We feature low on the innovation (No. 75 among 132 countries) and quality of education (No. 87) rankings in the World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report 2010-2011. On the first list, India is at 39, China at 26, and Malaysia at 24. On the second, Malaysia is at 23, India at 39, and China at 53. The key is both innovation and incubation, necessary drivers for entrepreneurship and economic growth.
Universities are the most important producers of knowledge and research, paving the path for innovation. Some have been innovation houses themselves. A study of startups established by MIT graduates, faculty and the university itself shows that, as of 2006, the turnover of these businesses totaled $11 trillion, roughly the size of Korea's current GDP. The USC Stevens Institute for Innovation is another success story. One of its many innovations: it has developed a method of treating deadly glioma brain tumors with chemotherapy delivered by inhalation.
Knowledge partnerships are crucial for economic ascendancy. During a visit to Carnegie Melon’s National Robotics Engineering Center in June, President Obama stated the obvious when he said technological innovations can help create jobs and spur growth. He proposed the government work with universities and corporations to reignite the American economy through an emphasis on cutting-edge research and new technologies.
Innovation, creativity, and learning have been proven to yield greater sustainable growth than brick-and-mortar investments. A recent U.S. Department of Commerce report found that $10,000 invested in business incubators can create up to 45 jobs, while the same amount invested in infrastructure projects, like building roads, can create only up to five. Business incubation programs focus on providing a knowledge-based support system to new enterprises, hastening their spurt from startup to sustainability.
Startups supported by incubators have a greater success rate. According to the National Business Incubation Association, some 41,000 U.S.-based startups that utilized incubators had an 87 percent survival rate compared to 44 percent for companies that did not. These small startups help job generation. A study by the Kauffman Foundation found that such businesses created almost two thirds of all new jobs in the past four years. And they are good businesses in themselves. There are over 1,200 incubators in the U.S., and at least 6,000 around the world. Canada’s Innovacorp generates over $279 million in export revenues and employs some 1,455.
The Obama administration realizes innovation is the cornerstone of growth. In his State of the Union address, Obama called for investing more than 3 percent of GDP on research, with $50 billion on university research. If successful, it would mean more university graduates; higher standards of science, technology, engineering and math education; and community college programs more in line with market demands. The obvious motivation for this program is the threat of an educated East overtaking the world’s greater superpower.
In 2008, for the first time, Asian companies and governments invested more in research and development ($387 billion) than North America ($384 billion) or Europe ($280 billion). The money was well spent. There are now over 500 incubators in China, 300 in South Korea, 200 in Japan, 100 each in Malaysia and Taiwan, 60 in India, and 43 in Turkey. Pakistan only has one. Countries which banked on innovation and incubation have done well. South Korea has been able to increase GDP from $3.9 billion in 1960 to $264 billion in 1990 by focusing on education and R&D. Finland’s Nokia has more export earnings than Pakistan.
India grasps the concept. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh approved the formation of a National Innovation Council (NIC) in August 2010. The council has been tasked with preparing a roadmap for a “Decade of Innovation 2011-2020,” focusing on inclusive growth and creating an innovation ecosystem. It bears repeating that Pakistan must focus on investing in higher education, research, innovation, and entrepreneurship. There is no choice in the matter.
[Editor's Note: The published version of this article cites $2 trillion as the overall turnover of MIT-affiliated companies. As per the ADB, this value should be $11 trillion. We regret the error.]