One week after the Supreme Court of Pakistan ordered her release, a Christian woman who has spent eight years on death row for blasphemy remains in prison, with no immediate prospect of freedom.
Thousands of Islamists poured onto the streets in protest after Supreme Court judges overturned Aasia Bibi’s conviction, in a case that has laid bare the divisions between traditionalists and modernizers in the Muslim-majority nation.
Ultra-conservative Islamists blockaded major cities to demand her immediate execution, in a three-day standoff that ended when Prime Minister Imran Khan’s administration agreed to allow a review of the Supreme Court’s ruling.
Critics blasted the climb-down—which came just days after Khan vowed to confront the protesters—as another capitulation to religious conservatives.
The deal has left Bibi in legal limbo—and languishing in jail for a crime of which she has been acquitted. “Aasia Bibi is in Multan jail and has not been released yet. We have not received orders to release her so far,” said Zawar Hussain Warraich, minister for prisons in Punjab province. “Normally we receive orders in two days after court judgment and if relatives and lawyers of a prisoner are very active, they can bring it even within a day, but as far as Aasia Bibi is concerned, it has not happened yet,” Warraich added. “Supreme Court should issue a directive to send us her release orders. We will release her as soon as we get it.”
He denied reports that extra security had been laid on for Bibi, saying “she is already well protected by the jail staff.”
An appeal has been filed with the court against Bibi’s release and the party that headed the protests demanding her execution, Tehreek-e-Labaik Pakistan, has warned its hardliners were prepared to take to the streets again.
Blasphemy is an incendiary charge in Muslim-majority Pakistan, where even unsubstantiated allegations of insulting Islam can result in death at the hands of mobs.
The case stems from an incident in 2009 when Bibi was asked to fetch water while out working in the fields. Muslim women laborers objected, saying that as a non-Muslim, she should not touch the water bowl, and reportedly a fight erupted. A local imam then claimed Bibi insulted Islam’s Prophet—a charge she has consistently denied.
Bibi’s husband Ashiq Masih has appealed for Britain or the United States to grant the family asylum, while her lawyer has fled to the Netherlands. Masih said the delay in releasing his wife, a mother of five, was adding to the family’s agony.
“The daughters are weeping. They still haven’t seen their mother. The family is totally shattered,” he said.